BLOG

Why Your New Year’s Resolutions Fade, and How to Make Them Last

Why Your New Year’s Resolutions Fade, and How to Make Them Last

Why is it that the notebook you opened so hopefully in January is the first thing you stop reading in March? The festive food is gone, the bank balance is lower than it should be, and the page that you headed into the new year with is still waiting.

During the season for resolutions, we write them with a sense of relief, as though the calendar itself were granting us a second chance. This year will be different. The frustrations of the past year are behind us. The energy is real.

Then, somewhere around the edge of spring, it all fizzles out.

The sunset effect

Think of a sunset. In the beginning, there is a blaze, warmth, and light across the entire sky. Then, slowly, the heat leaves. What remains is beauty to admire, but not the force that lit the day.

Resolutions are similar to that illustration. We can still read our lists and feel their brilliance as they are. The plans are good. The ideas are right. However, the energy to carry them out has gone.

Some people carry the same fire throughout the whole year, and I congratulate them. This article is for the rest of us, those who start well and fall short, and then privately wonder what is wrong with us.

There is nothing wrong with you. There is something wrong with the shape of the goal.

The real problem: a year is very long

My reasoning is simple. A year-long resolution is much harder to maintain than a single, one-time effort.

Weight loss is a classic example. After weeks of eating cake during the festive season, the wish to lose a few kilos makes perfect sense. However, “go to the gym, eat less, walk more, all year” is a marathon of daily decisions that must be made. “Go to the gym for one month and shed 5 kilos” is a sprint. You can see the finish line.

Or think of housework. Cleaning an entire house in one weekend is demanding but doable. Cleaning it twice a week for 12 months is entirely different.

I am not telling you to give up year-long plans. You need them. I am saying that they are hard, and that the hardness is not a flaw in you. It is a property of long goals. Once you know that, you can plan for it.

Five ways to keep the fire

1. Treat it as an art to be mastered. Anything that you want to be good at takes practice. Moreover, practice survives longer when it is interesting. Ask: How can I do this creatively? How can I make this something I want to return to?

2. Make it concrete and achievable. “Be healthier” is a wish. “Walk for twenty minutes after lunch on weekdays” is a plan. You are not trying to torture yourself into improvement. You are trying to build something you can actually live in.

3. Know what you really want from it. Is it the weight you want to lose or the way you hope to feel afterwards? Is it the achievement or the person you become by showing up? When you can name the deeper reason, you can hold on to it on days when the surface goal feels dull.

4. Ask whose resolution this is. It is easy to be swept up in the buzz around us and write what everyone else is writing. A Forbes Health survey of 1,000 U.S. adults found that 62% feel pressured to set a resolution (Davis, 2023). Why do I have this goal? If you cannot answer, perhaps it was never yours. You decide how many goals you can carry. Fewer is almost always better.

5. Set markers along the road. A year is too long to see across. Mark the way with checkpoints: smaller points that tell you not only that you have moved, but that you are moving in the correct direction.

What the research adds

In a large experiment with more than a thousand participants, Oscarsson et al. (2020) found that resolutions framed as something to do or add, such as eating more vegetables, were more successful than those framed as something to avoid. Try writing your goal as something you will begin, not something you will stop.

If you live between cultures

The new year may not begin on the same date for both of you, and what counts as a worthy goal may differ too. In an intercultural marriage, it can help to make one resolution together, in a language you both feel comfortable in.

Questions people ask

What if I have already broken my New Year’s resolution? Then begin again. A resolution that has lapsed is not a failed one. Any Monday will do if you want to restart.

Is it better to have one resolution or several resolutions? You decide what you can carry with you. Fewer are almost always easier to maintain.

Begin again, as often as needed

If your resolution has already faded, it is not too late, and you do not have to wait until next January. Any Monday is a good time to begin again.

Here is to a life where the resolutions we make are the ones we get to keep.

If a goal has been weighing on you for longer than a season, please feel free to get in touch.

Can I control my emotions?

Anxiety attack: why you cannot just calm down

References

Davis, S. (2023, December 4). New Year’s resolutions statistics. Forbes Health. https://www.forbes.com/health/mind/new-years-resolutions-statistics/

Oscarsson, M., Carlbring, P., Andersson, G., & Rozental, A. (2020). A large-scale experiment on New Year’s resolutions: Approach-oriented goals are more successful than avoidance-oriented goals. PLOS ONE, 15(12), Article e0234097. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0234097